Article courtesy of Ariel Emmanuel (King & Spalding)
Stermer v. Old Republic Nat’l Title Ins. Co. (In re ATIF, Inc.), No. 23-10850 (11th Cir. Nov. 24, 2025).
In 2008, like many other entities impacted by the Great Recession, the Attorneys’ Title Fund Services, LLC (or “ATIF” for short) was struggling financially. As the Eleventh Circuit eloquently put it, the cause of the financial trouble was “defalcations” by ATFS’ attorney-agents, which subsequently caused a dip in the entity’s investment portfolio and a drop in income.
Recognizing the perilous position ATFS was in, Old Republic National Title Insurance Company (“OR Title”), its Holdings (“OR Holding”) and subsidiaries (collectively, the “OR Defendants”) entered to save the day. In 2009, ATFS and OR began a joint venture, Attorneys’ Title Fund Services, LLC (“ATFS”). OR Holdings infused $10 million into ATFS and ATIF contributed its staff, network of agents, and title plant. The JV was to no avail, ATIF continued hemorrhaging cash, and in 2011, the parties amended the JV to enable an independent board to govern ATFS’s business activities, remove ATFS’s financial stake in the JV (switching it instead to a governance only stake) and allowing OH Holding a call option in to oust ATIF’s interest in ATFS.
Finally, in 2015, ATIF’s financial circumstances declined even more. ATIF faced three options: (1) be forced into a receivership by the Florida Department of Financial Services, (2) sell for $1.00 per share, or (3) accept OR Title’s reinsurance proposal. ATIF entered into a Master Agreement with OR Title for reinsurance, pursuant to which OR Title took over all of the ATIF’s policy and reinsurance liabilities and the title plant and ATIF transferred $47.5 million in assets to OR Title. It’s this transfer that led to the claims addressed when in 2016, OR Holdings divested ATFS from the joint venture and, in 2017, ATIF filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy.
The Creditor Trustee asserted claims alleging that (1) the OR Defendants did not pay reasonably equivalent value for the property transferred to them and (2) moved for summary judgment on the basis that OR Holdings was the alter ego of the ATFS entity.
In the lower court, the Court ruled that the Creditor Trustee did not satisfy the burden of proof to establish that the OR Defendants did not pay reasonably equivalent value for ATIF’s assets. In reaching this decision, the court excluded the Creditor Trustee’s proffered expert testimony on the value of ATIF’s assets, finding it unreliable. The Court also granted summary judgment to the OR defendants, finding that there was no intent to defraud creditors on the part of ATIF or OR Holdings and that ATFS did not qualify as the Debtor’s successor in interest or alter ego.
On appeal, the Eleventh Circuit addressed the questions of (1) whether the Creditor Trustee’s Expert was properly excluded, (2) whether the Court erred in granting summary judgment against the Creditor Trustee’s fraud and alter ego claims.
First, applying Federal Rule of Evidence 702 and the Daubert standard, the Court acknowledged that the Creditor Trustee’s expert admitted on the stand that his valuation was not based on “textbooks or treatises,” and the expert’s testimony double-counted intangible assets that were no longer in possession of ATIF at the time of the transfer. The Court stressed the importance of reliability to Rule 702, which assesses reliability according to Daubert and determined that the District Court did not err in excluding testimony which displayed flawed reasoning and little basis.
The Creditor Trustee’s arguments in favor of summary judgment included that (1) the Master Agreement transferred all of ATIF’s assets, (2) that ATIF had been threatened with suit pre-transaction, and (3) that ATIF was insolvent or became so because of the transfer. In assessing whether summary judgment was appropriately granted, the Court considered the badges of fraud. The Court began with the first argument, placing significant emphasis on the fact that not only was the transfer not concealed, it was explicitly approved by the Florida Office of Insurance Regulation, after a process which included the initial rejection of the deal. The Court also determined that OR Holdings did not qualify as an insider, given that the relationship between the two parties did not qualify as “arm’s length” where both parties had separate ownership, there was a well-documented business relationship, and no coercion into the transaction was present. The Court noted that the Creditor Trustee’s points on the size of the transfer were not convincing because he failed to meet his burden of proof on the size of ATIF’s assets at the time of the transfer. Finally, the Court placed great emphasis on the “legitimate purpose” of the transfer, which was designed to protect ATIF’s policyholders.
Regarding the Creditor Trustee’s successor in interest claim, the decision turned on the distinction between ATFS’ and ATIF’s assets. Where ATFS and ATIF did not share the same assets (despite the transfer of some intellectual property, a copy of a title plant, and employees), the Court declined to hold that the relationship between ATIF and ATFS rose to the level of a de facto merger.
Under Florida law, alter-ego claims and the doctrine of piercing the corporate veil are governed by the same factors. The Court held that the Creditor Trustee only satisfied one prong of the three-prong test: while OR Holding “arguably” dominated and controlled ATFS, it did not use the transferred funds for a fraudulent scheme, and there was no injury to the Debtor’s creditors where most of the claims filed by creditors were pre-2009 claims. Thus, the Eleventh Circuit affirmed the District Court on all counts.
