Article courtesy of Ariel Emmanuel (King & Spalding)
In re: Payroll Management, Inc. v. United States of America Internal Revenue Service et. al., No. 22-12336, 2025 (11 Cir. Jan. 2025)
The debtor sued BP for economic losses in connection with the 2010 Deepwater Horizon explosion. BP created a settlement fund that the plaintiffs in the various economic loss lawsuits could participate in, in lieu of pursuing their respective lawsuits. The settlement agreement was approved in December 2012, and the debtor submitted a claim to the settlement fund. In 2013, the debtor began missing federal tax payments on its employees as its financial condition deteriorated. In October 2015, the debtor obtained workers compensation insurance from Sunz Insurance Company (“Sunz”). Sunz required the debtor to enter into a security agreement, granting security over the debtor’s assets, including all tangible and intangible property. Sunz recorded its security agreement on November 3, 2015 with the Florida Secured Transaction Registry. In 2017, the debtor defaulted on its obligations to Sunz and continued to miss more federal employment tax payments. By March 2017, the IRS filed a $23 million federal tax lien notice against the debtor with the Florida Secretary of State. In December 2017, the claims administrator for the settlement fund determined that the debtor was eligible for a $1,070,330.23 settlement. The debtor was required to sign a release in order to receive payment on the settlement. The debtor filed for chapter 11 bankruptcy in March 2018, prior to signing the release. Sunz filed an adversary complaint against several the debtor’s other creditors, claiming that Sunz had a perfected first priority security interest in the settlement payment. Sunz claimed that it had a security interest over the debtor’s contracts and the proceeds thereof, and the settlement agreement was a contract. The IRS disagreed, claiming that the settlement was a commercial tort claim, not a contract when their federal tax lien notice was filed. The IRS claimed that Sunz security interest did not attach to the commercial tort claim, but their federal tax lien automatically attached. The bankruptcy court granted a summary judgment in favor of the IRS, and the district court affirmed this decision.
When the litigation claim first arose, such claim was a commercial tort claim. Under Florida statutes, a commercial tort claim does not convert into a contract until it has been (1) settled and (2) reduced to a contractual obligation to pay. The Eleventh Circuit Court of Appeals determined that the settlement agreement did not by itself give the debtor the right to payment. It was not until the settlement claim process ended and the debtor signed the individual release (which occurred in March 2018) that the settlement claim became a contract. Under the Florida uniform commercial code (which applies to the Sunz security interest), a security interest over a commercial tort claim attaches when the debtor signs a security agreement that contains an explicit description of the commercial tort claim. And under federal law (which applies to the IRS federal tax lien), a security interest over a debtor’s assets, including commercial tort claims, attaches when taxes are assessed. Therefore, the IRS’s federal tax lien attached to all of the debtor’s assets, including commercial tort claims, when the debtor’s federal employment taxes were assessed and perfected when the IRS filed a federal tax lien notice in March 2017. At that time, the debtor’s BP settlement claim was still a commercial tort claim. Because the Sunz security agreement did not explicitly describe commercial tort claims as collateral, the Sunz security interest had not attached to the debtor’s settlement claim when the IRS’s tax lien perfected. So the Court of Appeals concluded that the IRS’s tax lien takes priority in the $1,070,330.23 settlement payment because the IRS’s tax lien perfected first.
