Article courtesy of Ariel Emmanuel (King & Spalding)
Building Specialties Company of Louisiana v. Roadwrxx LLC, No. 24-CA-72 (La. App. 5 Cir. Dec. 4, 2024)
On November 2, 2020, Roadwrxx, LLC completed an application for credit with Building Specialties. The application included, among other things, the following statement: “Should it become necessary to place this account for collections, I shall personally obligate myself and my corporation, if any, to pay the entire amount due . . .” The application was signed by Paul Bienvenu, with the title “Managing Member” of Roadwrxx. In 2023, Building Specialties sued Roadwrxx and Mr. Bienvenu, jointly and severally, for overdue payments on the underlying loan. Mr. Bienvenu claimed he should not be personally liable for amounts owed to Building Specialties because he signed the application in a representative capacity and not in his personal capacity. He also argued that the credit agreement for the loan did not contain a personal guarantee section, and he did not provide personal information consistent with personal guarantee applications. The trial court granted as summary judgment in favor of Building Specialties.
The court looked towards the four corners of the application for credit to determine the intention of the parties. The court determined that the aforementioned language from the application for credit clearly and unambiguously created a suretyship agreement in which Mr. Bienvenue personally guaranteed and obligated himself to pay any debts of Roadwrxx. The court stated that the contract must be enforced as plainly written. The court looked to precedent cases to find that the notation of “Managing Member” next to Mr. Bienvenu’s name was “merely a title identification” and does not “obviate” the clear and unambiguous language of the suretyship agreement created in the contract. The court also considered the fact that the Roadwrxx was already obligated to abide by the agreement, so to construe the Mr. Bienvenu’s signature to the application for credit as anything other than a personal guaranty would render the document worthless.
