Article courtesy of Amanda Singh (Eversheds Sutherland)
In re Urban Commons 2 West LLC, et al., Case No. 22-11509 (PB) (Bankr. S.D.N.Y. Mar. 4, 2025)
The Hotel That Couldn’t Reopen: Bankruptcy, Bids, and the Battle Over Section 363(f)
In November of 2022, five affiliated LLCs, which collectively owned long-term leasehold interests in a Battery Park City hotel, filed for Chapter 11 after defaulting on a $96 million mortgage issued by BPC Lender LLC that matured in 2020. With the hotel being shut down due to the COVID-19 pandemic and no refinancing options available, their only path forward was to market and sell the hotel lease interests. Despite efforts, the only qualifying bid came from the lender itself, submitting a $78.5 million credit bid. VIK Services Inc, a contractor holding a $189,000 mechanic’s lien, challenged the sale, arguing the lien couldn’t be wiped out under Section 363(f) of the Bankruptcy Code.
The key legal dispute centered on how to interpret Section 363(f)(5), which permits sales free and clear of liens if the lienholder could be compelled to accept monetary satisfaction in a legal or equitable proceeding. The Bankruptcy Court for the Southern District of New York (the “Court”) faced two competing interpretations: one broad (embraced by most bankruptcy courts) that allows such sales if a foreclosure or UCC sale would extinguish the interest, and a narrower one from Dishi v. Bay Condos, which requires the debtor itself to be able to bring a proceeding to eliminate the lien. The Court rejected the Dishi interpretation as overly restrictive and inconsistent with the statutory text, which is written in the passive voice and does not specify who must bring the proceeding.
Ultimately, the Court adopted a “realistic possibility” standard, reasoning that Congress intended Section 363(f)(5) to reflect practical state law alternatives, like foreclosure and UCC sales, which could extinguish liens. This interpretation aligns with the Bankruptcy Code’s broader structure, which relies heavily on state law to define property rights. The ruling reinforces debtors’ ability to liquidate encumbered assets efficiently while ensuring lienholders are adequately protected—striking a balance between maximizing asset value and honoring secured creditors’ rights.
