Article courtesy of Kevin Braun (Morgan, Lewis & Bockius LLP), Paige Forcier (Morgan, Lewis & Bockius LLP), and Ian Tomesch (Morgan, Lewis & Bockius LLP)
Trust f/b/o Dianne Rose u/a/ DTD 9/12/02 v. Levine, et al., 2023 WL 5310608 (D. Vt. August 17, 2023)
In 2012, Paul Rose and Virginia Kern obtained funding from the Rose Trust (the “Trust”) via Paul’s mother for Virginia to purchase and improve land. In 2018, a managing member of a limited liability company (the “LLC”) that had been formed to manage the property executed a promissory note (the “Note”), promising to pay the Trust amounts representing the Trust’s prior payments to Paul, Virginia, the LLC and a predecessor (since dissolved) limited liability company under a prior note, as detailed in an attached disbursement schedule. The Note included Delaware choice of law provisions. The LLC ultimately filed for chapter 7 bankruptcy in 2020, and the Trust filed proofs of claim based on the Note. The chapter 7 trustee objected to these claims. The bankruptcy court rejected these claims, holding that consideration for the Note cannot be built upon a commitment to honor a pre-existing obligation as it is deemed neither benefit nor detriment.
The Trust appealed, arguing the bankruptcy court erred because, among other things, the court should have found that the Note was an enforceable promissory note under the UCC. The district court reversed the bankruptcy court’s decision that the Note was unenforceable for lack of consideration under the Delaware UCC.
As to this claim and as a threshold matter, the district court recited two relevant UCC Article 3 provisions. First, UCC 3-104 as in effect in Delaware defines the requirements for negotiable instruments (including promissory notes), to include an unconditional promise to pay a fixed amount of money on demand or at a particular time and without further conditions beyond repayment. The court found the Note met these requirements and was therefore a negotiable instrument subject to Article 3. Next, UCC 3-303 as in effect in Delaware provides that an instrument is transferred for “value”, which includes “payment of, or as security for, an antecedent claim against any person, whether or not the claim is due”. The court interpreted Section 3-303(a)(3) to specifically include the issuance of a negotiable instrument in payment or as security for an antecedent claim against any person. Here, the Trust held an antecedent claim against the LLC. Later, the court cites comment 4 to Section 3-303, which states that the subsection “applies to any claim against any person, there is no requirement that the claim arise out of contract. In particular, the provision is intended to apply to an instrument given in payment of or as security for the debt of a third person, even though no concession is made in return.”
For the forgoing reasons, the court remanded the case for purposes of deciding whether the claim should be recharacterized under relevant caselaw.
